Are creatine tablets as good as powder?
Yes, if you take 3 to 5 g a day. We found no trial testing capsules against powder, but if the label says creatine monohydrate, it’s the same creatine. The catch is the count.
On this page
Are creatine tablets as good as powder?
They should be, as long as the dose is right. What fills your muscles is the amount: about 3 to 5 g a day for at least 4 weeks.
We found no trial that compares capsules with powder head to head. But a small UK study gave people creatine as a solid, either a tablet crushed in the mouth and swallowed or undissolved crystals in water. It was readily absorbed, and raised blood creatine five to six times.
The peak was about 20% lower than the same dose fully dissolved in a drink. That study measured one dose, not the weeks it takes to fill your muscles.
| Capsules or tablets | Powder | |
|---|---|---|
| What’s inside | Creatine monohydrate, if the label says so | Creatine monohydrate, if the label says so |
| Daily amount | 3 to 5 g | 3 to 5 g |
| How you take it | Several capsules, swallowed with water | One scoop, mixed and drunk straight away |
| Absorbed? | Yes, solid creatine is readily absorbed | Yes, about 99% is taken up or passed in urine |
Sources: Harris 2002; ISSN 2021
So pick the one you’ll take every day. If you hate the gritty drink, capsules are fine. Next, count how many you need.
How many creatine tablets a day?
That’s the catch. With powder you weigh one scoop. With capsules you count them out.
Find the creatine per capsule on the label. Divide 3 or 5 g by it.
| Creatine per capsule | For 3 g a day | For 5 g a day |
|---|---|---|
| 500 mg | 6 capsules | 10 capsules |
| 750 mg | 4 capsules | 7 capsules (5.25 g) |
| 1 g | 3 capsules | 5 capsules |
Sources: ISSN 2021; GB nutrition and health claims
Watch for “per serving”. A serving can be several capsules, so the tub may last fewer days than it looks.
The UK’s approved creatine claims are both for 3 g a day. That makes 3 g a sensible floor. More on dose in how much creatine per day.
Creatine monohydrate tablets or creatine HCl?
Monohydrate. The ISSN, a group of sports nutrition researchers, calls it the most studied and effective form.
Creatine HCl (hydrochloride) is a creatine salt. No paper shows salts fill muscles better than the same amount of monohydrate, and they hold less creatine per gram.
So HCl isn’t a stronger form. Check the label says creatine monohydrate. For more on forms, see the best creatine to buy.
Liquid creatine, chews and bars
Skip liquid creatine. In water, creatine turns into creatinine, a waste product, faster when warm or acidic. Makers have failed to make a stable drink with 3 to 5 g a serving.
Chews are a gamble. A US supplement maker tested 12 brands of creatine gummies in its own lab. Five held little to no creatine, and all the failures held creatinine.
| Form | What we know |
|---|---|
| Powder | Shows no breakdown over years, even stored warm |
| Capsules or tablets | Solid creatine is readily absorbed. Check the grams per capsule. |
| Gummies and chews | 5 of 12 gummy brands held little to no creatine in one maker’s test |
| Liquid creatine | Breaks down into creatinine once mixed in liquid |
| Creatine bars | No test found. Check the grams of creatine per bar. |
Sources: ISSN 2021; Harris 2002; SupplySide
Read more on creatine gummies. Prefer powder after all? Here’s how to mix and take it.
How to pick the best creatine capsules
UK Anti-Doping warns that labels can be inaccurate. It advises batch-tested products only, and checking the batch number before use.
Your creatine capsule checks
- Check the label says creatine monohydrate, not another form.
- Find the creatine per capsule, not just per serving.
- Work out how many capsules give you 3 to 5 g a day.
- Choose a batch-tested product (each batch checked for banned substances), and check the batch number before use.
- Take them every day, swallowed with water.
- Keep each serving to 10 g or less, as bigger doses may cause diarrhoea.
Sources: ISSN 2021; UK Anti-Doping
In the first few days you may hold a little extra water. It’s the most common side effect. See creatine benefits and side effects for the rest.
When to speak to a GP
Speak to a GP if:
- You have kidney disease. Some researchers suggest you check with your doctor first, to be safe.
- You have lasting or worrying symptoms that could be kidney disease, such as weight loss and poor appetite, swollen ankles, feet or hands, shortness of breath, tiredness, blood in your pee, or needing to pee more, mainly at night.
- You’re under 18. The ISSN accepts creatine only for young athletes in serious, supervised training who eat a well-balanced diet, know how to use creatine properly and stay within the recommended dose.
- You have a kidney blood test due. Creatine can raise creatinine, so tell whoever reads your result.
Never stop or change a prescribed medicine without your prescriber. Before a blood test, read does creatine raise creatinine?